Blogadda Who are you reading today?

Visit to discover Indian blogs

Tuesday, 11 May 2010

Promises that are made to be kept (Main Chup Rahungi)

Meena Kumari's versatality knew no bounds. She could drape herself in almost any cinematic garb. Though she's christened as Bollywood's golden era tragedienne, I feel she was equally deft in comedy and romance. In 1962, she proves that, with a range of parts in Aarti, Sahib Bibi aur Ghulam and Main Chup Rahungi. All three roles garnered her a Filmfare nomination, each. She eventually went on to win for Sahib Bibi aur Ghulam. And, rightly so...
I'm yet to see Aarti, a family drama revolving around love and lust. I've watched the sublime Sahib Bibi aur Ghulam and I'm stupified by its make. The film is a masterpiece, if you allow this understatement. It is profoundly ethereal. I need to watch it again very soon. I am mesmerised by Kumari's beauty and performance. Her enigmatic presence is breathtaking and her eyes are intoxicating!!! But, on that, some other day...

Here, I'm going to delve into A. Bhimsingh's social drama, Main Chup Rahungi, where Kumari plays Gayatri, a simple village girl who suffers for love. She is paired opposite a very handsome and robust Sunil Dutt (dashing as always). She's clothed in plain sarees, ties a neat plait but still looks ravishing, fresh and attractive. Kumari's charming innocence draws you. In the scene where Kamal (Dutt), the landlord's son, dupes her into believing that he is but a petty employee of the landlord, you actually feel how unsullied she is. The riverbank sequence (where Dutt tries to woo her atop a horse) is lovely! They make for a striking couple. You actually see Kumari trying comedy in this film. And, she is good at it. Another example is the Dilip Kumar starrer Kohinoor.
Gayatri's father is indebted to the landlord because the rich man rescued him from the gallows and sent his daughter to the city for education. Along with her father, Gayatri is forever grateful to the master. So, when she discovers that her lover is none other than the landlord's son, she is scared to overstep her brief and turns away his marriage proposal. But Kamal loves her dearly and is adamant on marrying her...Gayatri agrees hesitantly but tradegy is imperative!!
Steeped in melodrama (I don't grudge that), Gayatri's confrontation with her father-in-law, is heartbreaking. The selfish old man gleans a promise off her to stay away from his son and keep mum on the marriage. He mentally torments her into complying. She breaks down and ultimately vouches that she will keep his word. She hides the fact, from all and sundry that she is married to Kamal.
But, fate has other things in the form of a lovable and smoothtalking little boy, Shyam...This orphan is extremely adorable and tugs at your heart with his innocent one-liners, his characteristic mannerisms and his Tumi ho mata, pita tumi ho. Chitragupta composes hummable music for this film. The best, I think, are, Chand jaane kahaan and Koi bata de dil .
Meena Kumari's scenes with Sunil Dutt communicate with the romantic in you. She is pretty and he is handsome. She is shy, he is confident. She trembles from his touch, he woos her with elan!!!
But, most exciting are her scenes with wonderboy Shyam, who is Babloo in the film. Babloo gives rise to her motherly instincts. She cries with him, loves him and wants to hug him tight. The scene where she feeds him her tiffin is most effective... Babloo says, "One, two, three..." and Gayatri's peepers melt...(her mind flashes back to the wonderful time spent with Kamal). Really touching!!
The classroom scene is the best. Gayatri mistakes someone's else's prank to be Shyam's and canes him!!! The pain reaches her own it!! It's really well executed!!
This legendary actor swept movie lovers off their feet, each time she occupied the screen. With stunning looks, intense peformances and a personality so rivetting, Meena Kumari's act seemed absolutely effortless...and flawless.
Sunil Dutt is outstanding, too. His transformation from a carefree lover to a grief-striken, jilted husband is immaculate and poignant. In fact, he is terrific opposite Shyam. We have a popular artist paired opposite a new child actor!!! The sparks are conspicuous by their absence!!
The film is shouldered by a solid supporting cast of Mohan Choti, Jagirdar and Nana Palsikar. But, the strongest shoulder is that of multi-talented Meena Kumari. This diva simply takes the cake away...


  1. Nice post, but am waiting for the one on Sahib Bibi aur Ghulam. That should be explosive!

  2. Thank you. Yes, Even I am waiting for my attempt on Sahib Bibi aur Ghulam... I'll try and be explosive. Ha ha :)

  3. Oh I love that movie. I remember catching this muvi on DD1 while surfing TV one lazy sunday 3-4 years back (Class 11th, I think). This was the first B&W movie I saw and got hooked to them immediately. It was my first MEENA KUMARI EXPERIENCE! I second ur thoughts about this diva vehemently. She is truly a superstar. I loved her scenes with Shyam and the songs Koi bata de dil hai jahan, Chaand jaane kahan kho gaya, Khush raho ehle chaman. people say madhubala is the most beautiful actor Hindi film ever had. I say, Meena Kumari is second to none! be it looks, personality, performance, dialogue delivery - she is a ten on ten, the camera's delight.
    Speaking about the film, Sunil Dutt, though good, is no match to her as well as the child actor, though he tries hard.
    Moreover, some scenes do trip towards melodrama, esp the one b/w gayatri and Zamindar in the mandir, still I sat through them all just to keep watching the ravishing actor glide through her performance! There can never be another Meena Kumari. Never!

  4. @Punya: i second your passion for Meena Kumari. And, even I feel Madhubala was incomplete as an actor (I don't like her performances). Meena Kumari was completely ethereal.
    I love these kind of social dramas where you know that all will be right in the end. And, I also love Sunil Dutt. He was awesome in Mera Saaya. But yes, you are right. There cant be another Meena Kumari. Thanks for the comment and keep reading :)

  5. @Sharmi: Haven't seen Mera Saya yet. Btw, I am also fond of such social-dramas. Though they were melodramatic (mostly) but they instill such a goody feeling.. warming up ur heart, that u can't help appreciating the good old hindi cinema. I escape to it whenever I feel the ruthless tentacles of stress clawing me from all sides. Its such a cosy refuge :)

  6. @Punya: Mera Saaya is a courtroom thriller. I'm sure you will love it. Yes, like you even I seek refuge in old hindi films. They give me sheer bliss :)

  7. Great Post on the grand dame herself, i simply love her and i'll surely get this on my next shopping trip

  8. @Bollywooddeewana: Thank you so much. Yes, this is an enjoybale drama with good acting and nice songs. Watch it :)

  9. Hi!.. Am so happy to read your blog and comments by you and Punya on Meena Kumari - which I totally agree with. She was just incomparable as an actress..the looks, her eyes, her voice, her diction...her performances in Baiju Bawra, Parineeta, Miss Mary, Azaad, DAPP, Sahib Bibi, Aarti, Mai Chup Rahungi, BHabhi ki Chudiya (I can't seem to get a copy of Baadban but I hear that was one of her best!) and so many others are just out of this world. She lived a largely unhappy life (especially in her later years) but has left these priceless treasures for generations to come!